How to generate insurance leads and keep clients

By The IFTTT Team

February 16, 2024

How to generate insurance leads and keep clients
  • In today's competitive insurance market, the ability to generate high-quality leads stands as a critical element for business growth and sustainability. Insurance leads are potential customers who have expressed interest in purchasing an insurance policy and are the lifeblood of any insurance agency or brokerage.

    Generating insurance leads is not just about increasing the number of potential clients; it's about bringing in those who are most likely to convert into policyholders. The more relevant and qualified the leads, the higher the chance of conversion, which ultimately leads to increased revenue and profitability for the business.

    Now that you are convinced of how important insurance leads can be for your growth, it's time to figure out how to drive these leads. In this guide, we'll explore the various ways to generate quality insurance leads for your business. Finally, we will introduce IFTTT, which can assist in driving growth in a variety of sectors.

    join today button

    Understanding insurance leads

    photo-1450101499163-c8848c66ca85 (1)

    Insurance leads are in essence potential customers who have expressed an interest in purchasing an insurance policy. They can be individuals looking for personal insurance solutions such as home, auto, or life insurance, or businesses seeking commercial insurance policies.

    Leads typically come into the picture when they provide their contact information in exchange for something of value like a free quote, an informative newsletter, or a detailed eBook. This exchange usually happens through various channels like an insurance company's website, social media platforms, or even at a physical location or event.

    It's important to note that in lead generation, quality often trumps quantity. While having a large number of leads might look impressive, it's the conversion rate that truly matters. Generating a small number of high-quality leads that are likely to convert is more valuable than attracting a large number of low-quality leads that will never translate into business.

    Therefore, insurance companies should focus their efforts on attracting and nurturing high-quality leads. This approach not only boosts conversion rates but also improves the efficiency of the sales process, leading to increased revenue and business growth.

    Traditional methods of generating insurance leads


    Traditional methods, or ones that are used outside of the internet, are often overlooked today but can be very effective if utilized correctly. Oftentimes, interacting with your company physically can leave a larger impact than interacting online. Here are some tried and true traditional methods to generate insurance leads:

    Networking: This is one of the oldest and most effective methods of generating insurance leads. Networking involves building relationships with individuals, businesses, and groups that can potentially provide leads. This could be through attending industry events, joining local business groups, or simply by leveraging existing relationships.

    Advertising (TV, radio, print): Traditional advertising mediums like television, radio, and print can still be effective, especially for reaching an older demographic that may not be as internet-savvy.

    Direct mail: Despite living in a digital age, direct mail marketing can still be quite effective for lead generation. A well-crafted direct mail piece can grab attention, especially if it offers a tangible benefit such as a free insurance quote or consultation.

    Telemarketing: Telemarketing involves reaching out to potential customers directly over the phone. While this method can be time-consuming and has a reputation for being intrusive, it allows for direct and immediate communication with potential leads. When done professionally and respectfully, telemarketing can yield positive results.

    Digital methods to generate insurance leads


    Digital methods of generating insurance leads are the future, and for obvious reasons. Reaching a large audience of potential customers has never been easier, not to mention targeted ads and demographic data can help point you in the right direction. Here are some of the most popular digital methods:

    Search Engine Optimization (SEO): SEO involves optimizing your website and its content to rank higher in search engine results, making it easier for potential customers to find you. This includes using relevant keywords, creating high-quality content, and building a website that offers a great user experience.

    Pay-Per-Click (PPC) advertising: PPC advertising is a model where you pay a fee each time someone clicks on your online ad. These ads can appear in search engine results or on social media platforms. The advantage of PPC is that it can target specific demographics, locations, and even the time of day, making it a very effective tool for generating quality leads.

    Email marketing: Email marketing is essentially sending targeted messages to a group of individuals who have expressed interest in your services. It's an effective way to nurture leads, keep your brand top-of-mind, and encourage potential customers to take action.

    Social media marketing: Social media platforms like Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, and Instagram offer a unique opportunity to engage with potential customers on a more personal level. By maintaining a strong social media presence, insurance companies can attract leads, build relationships, and foster customer loyalty.

    The key to turning leads into customers


    Turning leads into customers involves a process known as lead nurturing - the practice of developing relationships with buyers at every stage of the sales funnel, and through every step of the buyer's journey.

    A good practice to note is that you should provide leads with value-added content that educates them about insurance policies and how they can benefit from them. This could be in the form of blog posts, eBooks, infographics, or even webinars.

    Engage with leads across multiple channels - email, social media, phone calls, etc. The idea is to be where your leads are, providing them with relevant content and interactions on the platforms they prefer.

    The importance of follow-ups and building relationships cannot be overstated. Consistent follow-ups remind leads of your offerings and show them that you are interested in serving their needs. Building relationships, on the other hand, fosters trust and loyalty, which not only increases the chances of converting leads into customers but also promotes customer retention.

    Insurance leads done right with IFTTT


    IFTTT (If This Then That) is our automation tool that can help insurance companies automate the process of generating leads. By creating connections between web-based services - such as websites, social media platforms, and even physical locations or events - you can set and forget about your lead-generating tasks.

    Read on to hear about our mission and our top picks for lead generation automations.

    What is IFTTT?

    IFTTT, an acronym for "If This Then That," is our free web-based service and mobile app designed to boost productivity by automating tasks. It works by creating connections between popular apps and services, allowing them to work together seamlessly.

    The basic idea behind IFTTT is to create "applets" or sets of instructions that trigger when certain conditions are met. This can be turning on the lights automatically when you enter your house, for example.

    Founded in 2011, IFTTT has been used by over 25 million individuals to automate both business and home tasks, saving time and increasing efficiency. It's commonly used to connect disparate services and systems, making all products and services work well together in a way that instills user confidence. Best of all, it's free and only takes a couple of minutes to set up.

    Top Lead Generation Applets

    Subscribe new Facebook Lead Ad leads to a Mailchimp list

    With this Applet, you can easily sync new leads obtained from Facebook Lead Ads with your Mailchimp list. This way, you can easily keep track of all incoming leads and manage them accordingly.

    Share newsletter performance with the team

    Boss keeps asking how the marketing campaign is going? Deliver quality reports before they are even asked for with this Applet, which will automatically share the performance of your campaign with a Slack channel.

    Get a notification when you get a new JotForm submission

    Stay informed of when potential clients fill out your JotForm with this Applet. This way, you can quickly respond to leads before they get cold.

    To enable these Applets and millions more (yes, millions), try IFTTT today for free!

    join today button